Innovation on the plate: the start-ups reshaping Italian cuisine and the crucial role of liquidity
The Italian agri-food sector is undergoing a quiet but profound transformation, far from the spotlight focused on cultured meat and novel foods; whilst public debate centres on these issues, an army of start-ups, innovative SMEs and spin-offs is already reshaping the food supply chain from farm to fork, and the report “Next-Gen Food – The Future of Food, the Food of the Future’, produced by Cariplo Factory (now Factory Plus), which paints a picture of great technological vitality, but also of structural fragility.
Perhaps the most surprising finding to emerge from the report is not the creation of new businesses, but their level of maturity, as the majority of the companies surveyed have reached such a level of technological readiness that their solutions have moved beyond the prototype stage and have been validated in a live operating environment, whilst a significant proportion are even operating with technologies that have been fully validated on the market; these are therefore no longer pipe dreams, but concrete solutions ready to be scaled up.
The ecosystem spans the entire supply chain, with precision farming and on-farm innovation representing one of the most significant sectors, followed by food processing and consultancy services; many companies operate in at least two of these areas simultaneously, reflecting an interdisciplinary approach that combines sensors, satellite data and artificial intelligence to achieve more efficient farming that reduces water and fertiliser consumption, right through to biocompatible sensors installed directly in plants to anticipate stress conditions. There is no shortage of solutions for supply chain management, such as smart labels that monitor the cold chain or plant-based coatings that extend the shelf life of fresh produce, and digital platforms to optimise logistics and reduce waste, whilst in the field of alternative proteins, some start-ups are transforming agri-food by-products into functional ingredients through fermentation processes, and others are developing technologies to convert carbon dioxide into high-biological-value proteins without using agricultural land or water.
This transformation also extends to the relationship between diet and health, with personalised nutrition platforms powered by artificial intelligence and wearable devices to detect the presence of substances in food, whilst blockchain technology is being used to certify the origin and quality of products, combating counterfeiting and increasing transparency throughout the supply chain, and according to the entrepreneurs interviewed, it is artificial intelligence that will drive the next phase of the sector’s transformation, identified as the technology set to have the greatest impact in the coming years.
However, the report highlights a challenge as significant as the ecosystem’s potential: the difficulty in accessing capital, and it is here that the issue closely touches on the mission of those, such as the Camera di Compensazione, who work to streamline financial flows between businesses, because the majority of companies interviewed cite the scarcity of funding as the main obstacle to development, and this lack of liquidity limits the ability to transform a validated innovation into an industrial-scale enterprise.
The investment landscape reveals a fragmented market, where sources of capital are diverse and only minimally structured, with accelerators and incubators representing one of the main routes to capital, followed by venture capital, business angels and, to a lesser extent, public funding. It is telling that a significant proportion of funding comes from family and friends’ networks – a figure that exceeds that of venture capital – highlighting the extent to which the traditional financial system remains reluctant to back agri-food innovation, which is perceived as risky or having long payback periods. The picture is further complicated by the geographical concentration of investment, with the majority of capital raised concentrated in companies in the North, where Lombardy is home to a significant proportion of businesses, thereby widening the gap with the rest of the country. Meanwhile, the geographical distribution highlights one of the main structural limitations of Italian innovation, with the North absorbing the majority of resources and leaving the South on the sidelines, despite some southern regions emerging as hubs of innovation.
Unless solutions are found to this structural problem, the risk is very real and serious: that of a slowdown in innovation, because technologies set to change the way we produce and consume food risk remaining isolated examples of excellence, unable to become a competitive advantage for the country as a whole. This is not merely a matter of stunted growth for individual start-ups, but of a loss of opportunity for the entire agri-food sector, which represents a vital part of the national economy.
The requests that entrepreneurs are making to the authorities also reflect this emergency: greater regulatory certainty, more financial instruments and private investors, and more public funding. Underlying these requests is the need for a more stable and predictable environment in which to invest and grow, as well as a more developed capital market, whilst some of those interviewed report persistent consumer mistrust of food innovation and others struggle to find suitable skills.
It is against this backdrop that initiatives such as those of the Camera di Compensazione can play an unexpectedly strategic role, because whilst foodtech start-ups struggle to access venture capital or traditional bank financing due to their innovative nature and often lack of physical collateral, the mechanism of multilateral clearing could offer an alternative route to unlocking liquidity. Start-ups and innovative SMEs, even whilst in their growth phase, often have commercial relationships with suppliers, distributors and customers, and it is precisely within these relationships that untapped liquidity potential lies; for if a company producing sensors for precision agriculture has a receivable from a major distributor and, at the same time, an outstanding debt to a supplier of electronic components, a clearing platform can identify multilateral payment chains that allow immediate liquidity to be unlocked without having to wait for standard payment terms. Even a ‘small’ amount resulting from netting can make the difference between a project moving forward and one coming to a standstill. Netting does not replace venture capital or public funding, but it can act as a liquidity bridge to overcome periods of heightened financial strain, allowing businesses to focus their efforts on product development and market entry, rather than on managing cash flows.
The growth in investment is showing encouraging signs but is far from over, with many companies already seeking new funding rounds and a significant proportion aiming to raise substantial sums, and the most interesting finding concerns not so much the emergence of new companies as the level of maturity achieved by the ecosystem, with many firms having received awards and recognition and having already secured investment – a sign that the quality of the technologies now appears well-established, but the main challenge is the ability to transform innovation into industrial growth. In organisational terms, male-led teams still predominate, but the report highlights some interesting trends: start-ups founded exclusively by women have received recognition at an above-average rate and participate significantly in accelerator programmes, whilst continuing to raise smaller funding rounds than male-led or mixed-gender teams. This demonstrates that the potential is there, but the conditions to fully realise it are still lacking.
The “Next-Gen Food” report paints a clear picture: Italy possesses a technically mature, creative agri-food innovation ecosystem capable of tackling global challenges such as food security, sustainability and waste reduction; the challenge in the coming years will therefore not be to generate new ideas, but to create the conditions for them to scale up – a transition that requires a joint effort: on the one hand, public policies that guarantee greater regulatory stability and financial support; on the other, the development of a capital market that overcomes its current fragmentation and reluctance.
In this process, innovative financial instruments such as multilateral clearing can make a concrete and immediate contribution, transforming commercial relationships into a vital source of liquidity to ensure that the future of Italian food is not nipped in the bud; for without a more developed capital market, more stable regulations and easier access to distribution, there is a risk that many of the technologies set to change the way we produce and consume food will remain isolated examples of excellence, rather than becoming a competitive advantage for the country as a whole, and the history of innovation teaches us that major transformations do not arise solely from laboratories but also from the ability to find the resources to bring them to market; in this sense, liquidity is not just a figure – it is the fuel that enables ideas to travel from the entrepreneur’s mind to the consumer’s table; it is the bridge that transforms a prototype into a product, a start-up into an industry, and a dream into reality.
Follow our journey and stay up to date: www.nexyzen.com